The Republican price range reconciliation package deal, signed into legislation on July 4th, will—for the primary time—require some people enrolled in Medicaid to satisfy work requirements as a situation of eligibility. When carried out by January 2027 (or sooner at state possibility), adults enrolled by the Medicaid enlargement and sure adults enrolled in Medicaid waiver applications in Wisconsin and Georgia, will probably be required to work or take part in work-related exercise for 80 hours or extra a month or attend faculty half time. The legislation exempts sure people from the necessities, together with mother and father of kids ages 13 and youthful, people who find themselves medically frail, and individuals who meet related work necessities within the Supplemental Vitamin Help Program (SNAP). The legislation additionally permits states to permit for short-term hardship exceptions for people who stay in areas of excessive unemployment, the place it might be harder to discover a job.
This concern temporary describes the hardship exception for people residing in counties with excessive unemployment, and utilizing the newest out there county-level unemployment information from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and county-level Medicaid enlargement enrollment information, estimates the variety of counties that might meet the standards for this exception and the variety of enlargement enrollees residing in these counties who could possibly be exempt from the work necessities. As a result of county-level enrollment information for enrollees who could be topic to work necessities in Georgia and Wisconsin should not out there, this evaluation solely contains enlargement states.
Primarily based on this evaluation, the scope of this hardship exception could also be restricted; simply 7% of counties meet the excessive unemployment standards utilizing a 12-month common unemployment fee and seven% of enrollees stay in these counties and could possibly be exempt if their state requests the hardship exception. Nevertheless, how CMS operationalizes the standards will have an effect on the variety of counties and enrollees that qualify. Permitting states to establish counties that meet the standards utilizing 6-month or 3-month common unemployment charges along with the 12-month common fee would improve the variety of counties that qualify. Additionally, whereas the present nationwide unemployment fee is low, modifications within the financial system and a tightening job market may trigger unemployment charges to rise. If unemployment charges improve, the variety of enrollees who would qualify for this hardship exception would additionally improve.
What’s the Excessive Unemployment Charge Hardship Exception?
The legislation permits states to request a hardship exception for people who stay in counties with excessive unemployment charges. Particularly, the legislation permits states to request exemptions for people who reside in counties which have unemployment charges at or above 8% or under 8% however 1.5 or extra instances the nationwide common unemployment fee. This exception is elective, however for states that request the exception and obtain approval, all people who reside in counties that meet the standards could be exempt from the work necessities for a specified time frame. The language within the reconciliation package deal is just like the statutory language that defines a waiver exemption to the work necessities in SNAP, which allows states to request exemptions for areas which have unemployment charges over 10% or that lack a enough variety of jobs.
The legislation grants the Secretary of Well being and Human Providers (HHS) discretion in how you can implement this hardship exception, together with what info states should submit. Whereas the legislation lays out the broad standards wanted to satisfy the exception, the Secretary may have the discretion to set the parameters for the way the standards will probably be operationalized, together with what info states should present, the size of the exception interval, and the method for making use of for the exception. These choices by the Secretary will have an effect on how straightforward it’s for states to use for the exception and finally what number of counties meet the standards and what number of enrollees will probably be exempt from the work necessities. The legislation requires the Secretary of HHS to concern an interim closing rule implementing the Medicaid work necessities by June 1, 2026.
CMS might look to present SNAP rules to assist information the standards for qualifying for an exception. CMS officers have indicated that they plan to comply with sub-regulatory steerage that already exists in different applications with related provisions, the place potential. Current SNAP regulations present choices for the info states can use to help a waiver request, together with a readily approvable waiver utilizing 12-month common unemployment charges. The regulation additionally specifies that the info states submit should depend on customary BLS information or strategies. Waivers are usually permitted for one yr; nonetheless, waivers could also be permitted for a shorter or longer interval, if deemed applicable. CMS might select to comply with the SNAP rules or enable for roughly flexibility within the information that states can use to establish counties with excessive unemployment. These choices will have an effect on the variety of enrollees who may qualify for the exception. States can select whether or not to use for the exception, and a few might resolve to not for ideological causes or as a result of few counties and enrollees would meet the standards. Notably, 18 states do not need SNAP work requirement waivers.
How Many Counties and Enrollees May Meet the Excessive Unemployment Exception?
KFF evaluation makes use of 12-month common county unemployment charges from June 2024 by Could 2025 to estimate the variety of counties that meet the standards for the excessive unemployment hardship exception. The 12-month common unemployment fee is the metric used within the readily-approvable SNAP exemption waivers. The evaluation then makes use of enrollment information for the enlargement inhabitants from the 2023 T-MSIS Analysis Identifiable Information to estimate the variety of enrollees who stay in qualifying counties and who could possibly be exempt from the work necessities if all states utilized for and had been granted the exceptions.
Nationally, 158 counties in enlargement states meet the excessive unemployment standards, and 1.4 million enrollees in these states may qualify for the hardship exception, accounting for 7% of counties and enrollees. Different strategies may have completely different results. For instance, utilizing a technique the place counties may qualify for the exception by assembly the unemployment standards in any month from June 2024 to Could 2025, 386 counties in 34 enlargement states had unemployment charges that met the standards. These counties represented 17% of all counties in enlargement states, and 4.6 million enlargement enrollees, or 23% of all enlargement enrollees, reside in these counties and could possibly be exempt from the work necessities.
Total, whereas 80% of counties that meet the standards are rural, over 80% of enlargement enrollees who could possibly be exempt from work necessities stay in city counties (Determine 2). Of the 158 counties with unemployment charges that meet the statutory standards, 126 are situated in rural areas. Due to the upper unemployment charges in rural areas, a barely bigger share of all rural counties in enlargement states meet the standards (8.5% of rural counties vs. 7% of all counties). Nevertheless, as a result of the inhabitants in rural areas is smaller, over 80% of enlargement enrollees who may qualify for the hardship exception stay in city counties. Of the 1.4 million enlargement enrollees who may qualify for the exception, simply 273,350 (19%) are in rural counties, accounting for 10% of all enlargement enrollees who stay in rural counties.
9 in ten enlargement enrollees who’re in counties that meet the excessive unemployment standards and could possibly be exempt from the work necessities stay in 5 states (Determine 3). Enlargement enrollees who stay in counties with excessive unemployment charges are concentrated in simply 5 states—California, New York, Michigan, Kentucky, and Ohio. Enlargement enrollees in California account for over 50% of all enrollees residing in counties that meet the standards. In New York, over 260,000 enlargement enrollees, representing 18% of all enrollees who could possibly be exempt, stay in Bronx County, the one county within the state to satisfy the excessive unemployment standards. Total, 93% of enrollees who could possibly be exempt stay in states with Democratic governors, who could be anticipated to request the exception. Throughout nearly all of enlargement states, nonetheless, the influence of the excessive unemployment hardship exception is small. In 9 states, 2,000 or fewer enlargement enrollees stay in counties that meet the standards, and in 17 states no counties meet the standards.
Rural enlargement enrollees who may qualify for the hardship exception are equally concentrated in seven states. Half of the 273,350 enlargement enrollees who stay in rural counties with unemployment charges that meet the standards and who could possibly be exempt from the work necessities stay in Kentucky and Michigan (Determine 3). One other 14% stay in California, 6% stay in Oregon, and 5% every stay in Arizona, Louisiana, and Ohio. As with counties total, the influence of this hardship exception in rural counties is restricted. Simply 10% of rural enlargement enrollees stay in qualifying counties, and in 20 enlargement states, no rural counties meet the excessive unemployment standards.
Appendix
